Our intrepid heroes wonder if Batman yelling at a suicidal is the best method of discouragement. The Casefile: Batman 309-10. Current books: Batman 4, Batman & Robin 4, Batgirl 4, Batwoman 4, Red Hood & the Outlaws 4, Nightwing 4, Detective Comics 4. We reveal our (and your) picks for best and worst of the Bat-universe for 2011.

Suggested topics of conversation include Batwoman's o-face, criminals who mean well, the chances of DC's relaunch success continuing, and kidnapped butlers.

The Band o' the Week is Bowling for Soup, with "A Hangover You Don't Deserve"

Get it Here